My top three products I use when removing my makeup at night are:
1) Cetaphil cleanser for all skin types
I love Cetaphil products because they are fragrance free and non-comedogenic, definitely friendly for even the most sensitive skin. Whether I am using the wipes or jojoba oil, I always use this to thoroughly cleanse my face and wash away anything that may have been left over. This can be found at any drug store such as CVS or Target.
2) Neutrogena Makeup Wipes
I have always used these makeup wipes since my first days of wearing cosmetics. I normally use these if I am not showering (where I will normally wash my face) or if I am unable to wash my face, either because I am too tired or not at home. They take off my makeup well, but I am never 100% comfortable unless I cleanse afterward as well. They are also good for cleaning up a cat liner, fallout, or creating a clean straight line for shadow! I often buy it in bulk at Costco. Great deal!
3) Jojoba Oil (I purchased mine at Trader Joes)
Ever heard of using olive oil to remove your makeup? Well this is the same idea, and in my experience less oily and messy. When using oil to remove makeup, you need to make sure you completely wash it off afterwards. Be sure to pour it onto a cotton round and let it soak on top of.your eye makeup to break it down. Be sure to very gently wipe it off and follow up with a cleanser and toner. Jojoba oil can also be used to moisturize the body!